If there is music that can break out and yet exist in that quiet, probable space between the Earth and the stars… then it is the work of Joan As Police Woman.

A force of nature created by and reflecting the tragedy and beauty of life, the songs of Joan Wasser fill St Luke’s with a fragility and strength that leaves the audience spellbound, and at times, the singer visibly emotional.

The new songs from the current album Lemons, Limes and Orchids feature heavily, aptly beginning with “The Dream” and ending with an encore that includes “Real Life.”

Quivering between hope and despair, songs like “Long to Ruin,” “Eternal Flame,” and “Started for Free” are perfect platforms for her mesmerising voice, delicate drums, guitar, and keyboard to deliver their message.

The decision to have two sets was inspired and allows the audience to mingle (as instructed) and discuss their shared experience. There is a sense of dismay that Joan As Police Woman isn’t playing far, far larger venues, and that she is not universally known. There is also a sense of gratitude that one can be in such close proximity to an artist at their peak — an artist who has collaborated with Lou Reed, John Cale, Rufus Wainwright, Tony Allen, David Byrne, Damon Albarn, Beck… the list goes on.

Those who are here know… and those who don’t will eventually find out.

It was one of those “I was there” nights.

Joan As Police Woman plays Edinburgh in January 2025. Be there.

Words & Photos: Chris Hogge